Cycle double cover conjecture
Status partial high confidence
The Cycle Double Cover Conjecture remains open; no complete proof has been accepted by the mathematical community, and several claimed arXiv proofs (2012, 2015, 2018) were later found to contain errors. Post-2007 progress includes a proof of Jaeger's directed version for lean fork-graphs, exponential lower bounds for the counting version for planar cubic graphs, and approximate results giving nontrivial upper bounds on singular edges in cubic graph embeddings.
Cited literature (4)
-
Proves Jaeger's directed cycle double cover conjecture for lean fork-graphs, an inductively defined class of cubic bridgeless graphs whose members contain subdivisions of all cubic bridgeless graphs as induced subgraphs.
-
Proves an exponential lower bound on the number of circuit double covers for planar bridgeless cubic graphs and an almost-exponential lower bound for graphs with surface embedding representativity at least 4, establishing the first counting results toward CDC.
-
Establishes nontrivial upper bounds on the minimum number of singular edges in a 2-cell embedding of a cubic graph (CDC being equivalent to achieving zero singular edges), giving an approximate version of the conjecture with efficient algorithms.
-
Studies circular 2-cell embeddings of cubic graphs via twist operations on edges, derives bounds on singular edges, and develops analytical tools further advancing the approximate CDC program.
Reviewer notes. Three arXiv preprints claim to prove the CDC conjecture (1202.0569, 1510.02075, 1811.08719); the 2015 paper (Radcliffe, arXiv:1510.02075) has a confirmed error noted on its own arXiv page. The Fischer 2023 paper (arXiv:2307.06649) claims to prove CDC for simple bridgeless triangle-free cubic graphs using percolation theory, but remains an unreviewed preprint as of March 2025. Wikipedia and the mathematical community confirm the conjecture is still open. Any minimal counterexample is known to have girth at least 12.
Discussion
This beautiful conjecture was made independently by Szekeres and Seymour in the 70's and is now widely considered to be among the most important open problems in graph theory. Note the similarity between this conjecture and the Berge-Fulkerson conjecture on perfect matchings. Attempts to prove this conjecture have lead to a variety of conjectured strengthenings, which appear on other pages. See: The circular embedding conjecture , The five cycle double cover conjecture , The faithful cover conjecture , and Decomposing Eulerian graphs . If a graph $ G $ has a nowhere-zero 4-flow then it follows from a result of Tutte that $ G $ satisfies the above conjecture. Thus, by Jaeger's 4-flow theorem [J], the above conjecture is true for every 4-edge-connected graph. A cubic graph has a nowhere-zero 4-flow if and only if it is 3- edge-colorable , so the above conjecture is also true for 3-edge-colorable cubic graphs. In general, it follows from vertex splitting arguments that problem may be reduced to cubic graphs which are not 3-edge-colorable. For a general graph $ G $ with no cut-edge, Bermond, Jackson and Jaeger [BJJ] used Jaeger's 8-flow theorem [J] to prove that $ G $ has a list of circuits so that every edge is contained in exactly four. Fan [F] used Seymour's 6-flow theorem [S81] to prove that G has a list of circuits so that every edge is contained in exactly six. Let $ G $ be a directed graph and let $ C $ be a circuit (not necessarily a directed circuit) of $ G $ . If we choose a direction to travel around $ C $ , then every edge of $ C $ is either traversed forward or backward. The following strengthening of the cycle double cover conjecture takes directions into account. Conjecture (The oriented cycle double cover conjecture) If $ G $ is an orientation of a bridgeless graph, then there is a list $ L $ of circuits of $ G $ with directions so that every edge of $ G $ is traversed forward by exactly one circuit in $ L $ and backward by exactly one circuit in $ L $ . Tutte also showed that every graph with a nowhere-zero 4-flow satisfies this conjecture. Thus, as above this conjecture is true for 4-edge-connected graphs and for 3-edge-colorable cubic graphs. It was mentioned above that for a general graph $ G $ with no bridge, there is a list of circuits containing every edge exactly four times. By taking two copies of each circuit in this list and giving them opposite directions, we have a list of circuits so that every edge is traversed forward and backward exactly four times. Luis Goddyn and I (M. DeVos) have observed that the same ideas used in Fan's article [Fa] can be used to construct a list of circuits with directions so that every edge is traversed forward and backward exactly three times. The following natural question seems to be open. Conjecture (The oriented cycle four cover conjecture) If $ G $ is an orientation of a bridgeless graph, then there is a list $ L $ of circuits of $ G $ with directions so that every edge of $ G $ is traversed forward by exactly two circuits in $ L $ and backward by exactly two circuits in $ L $ . Since every graph with a nowhere-zero 4-flow has a list of circuits with directions traversing every edge forward and backward exactly once, the above conjecture would follow from The three 4-flows conjecture.
Bibliography
-
[AGZ]B. Alspach, L. Goddyn, and C-Q Zhang, Graphs with the circuit cover property , Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 344 (1994), 131-154. MathSciNet Graphs with the circuit cover property · MathSciNet -
[BJJ]J.C. Bermond, B. Jackson, and F. Jaeger, Shortest covering of graphs with cycles, J. Combinatorial Theory Ser. B 35 (1983), 297-308. MRhref{0735197} -
[DJS]M. DeVos, T. Johnson, P.D. Seymour, Cut-coloring and circuit covering Cut-coloring and circuit covering -
[F]G. Fan, Integer flows and cycle covers, J. Combinatorial Theory Ser. B 54 (1992), 113-122. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[FZ]G. Fan and C.Q. Zhang, Circuit decompositions of Eulerian graphs, J. Combinatorial Theory Ser. B 78 (2000), 1-23. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[FG]X. Fu and L. Goddyn, Matroids with the circuit cover property , Europ. J. Combinatorics 20 (1999), 61-73. MathSciNet Matroids with the circuit cover property · MathSciNet -
[J]F. Jaeger, Flows and Generalized Coloring Theorems in Graphs, J. Combinatorial Theory Ser. B 26 (1979) 205-216. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[Ki]P.A. Kilpatrick, Tutte's First Colour-Cycle Conjecture, Thesis, Cape Town (1975). -
[Sz]G. Szekeres, Polyhedral decompositions of cubic graphs. Bull. Austral. Math. Soc. 8, 367-387. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[S91]P.D. Seymour, Nowhere-Zero 6-Flows, J. Combinatorial Theory Ser. B 30 (1981) 130-135. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[S79]P.D. Seymour, Sums of circuits in Graph Theory and Related Topics edited by J.A. Bondy and U.S.R. Murty, Academic Press, New York/Berlin (1979), 341-355. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[S95]P.D. Seymour, Nowhere-Zero Flows, in Handbook of Combinatoircs, edited by R. Graham, M. Grotschel and L. Lovasz, (1995) 289-299. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[T54]W.T. Tutte, A Contribution on the Theory of Chromatic Polynomials, Canad. J. Math. 6 (1954) 80-91. MathSciNet MathSciNet -
[T66]W.T. Tutte, On the Algebraic Theory of Graph Colorings, J. Combinatorial Theory 1 (1966) 15-50. MathSciNet MathSciNet