Planar crossing-free drawing in annulus
Conjecture 1.2 · arXiv:2410.13008
Status open high confidence
Conjecture 1.2 asks whether a strongly 2-connected digraph drawn (with crossings) in an annulus so that every directed cycle has winding number one can always be redrawn without crossings while preserving that winding-number condition. The author explicitly states 'we cannot prove it.' No verified follow-up paper resolving or refuting the conjecture was found in the literature as of May 2026; a co-authored paper by Seymour, Berger, and Carter titled 'When all directed cycles have the same weight' is listed as forthcoming but does not appear to address this conjecture directly.
Reviewer notes. The AI-generated summary from one search result claimed the conjecture was disproved by Daniel Carter, but direct WebFetch of the arXiv HTML (arxiv.org/html/2410.13008) found no mention of Carter and no counterexample — that claim is unverifiable and likely a hallucination. Seymour's publication page lists a forthcoming paper with Berger and Carter titled 'When all directed cycles have the same weight,' which is thematically related but distinct. No follow-up found after 5 web calls; status is open with high confidence given the conjecture is less than 2 years old.
Context
This conjecture arises from an analogy with Thomassen's theorem on acyclic digraphs: gluing the north and south sides of a rectangle produces an annulus, and the question becomes whether a drawing with crossings in the annulus can be continuously deformed to a crossing-free drawing while preserving winding numbers of directed cycles. The author states explicitly that 'we cannot prove it.'
Source paper
When all directed cycles have length three
Paul Seymour · 2025-02-09
https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.13008