Polynomial gain on symmetric intersecting vector families
Polynomial improvement on symmetric intersecting family size bound · arXiv:1909.11578
Status open medium confidence
The conjecture asks for constants $c, \delta > 0$ (possibly depending on $k$) such that every symmetric intersecting $A \subset [k]^n$ satisfies $\log_k |A| \leq n - cn^{\delta}$, a polynomial improvement over the qualitative $o(k^n)$ bound of Theorem 1.1 for fixed $k \geq 3$. Keller, Lifshitz, and Marcus (arXiv:2307.01356, 2023) prove the first quantitative upper bound in the transitive-symmetric vector-intersecting setting via sharp hypercontractivity, but their result applies only for $k$ growing with $n$ (specifically $2\log n \leq k \leq \sqrt{n}\log n$), leaving the fixed-$k$ case open. No paper resolving the polynomial improvement for fixed $k$ was found in the indexed literature.
Cited literature (1)
-
Proves the first quantitative upper bound on transitive-symmetric vector-intersecting families (Theorem 1.6): for $k \in [2\log n, \sqrt{n}\log n]$, any such family satisfies $|\mathcal{A}|/k^n \leq c_1 \exp(-c_2 k/\log n)$; this is a polynomial improvement in $n$ for $k$ polynomial in $n$, but does not address the fixed-$k$ regime targeted by the conjecture.
Reviewer notes. The conjecture targets fixed $k \geq 3$ with $n \to \infty$; arXiv:2307.01356 makes partial progress for $k$ growing with $n$ via sharp hypercontractivity (Theorem 1.6), but this regime does not overlap with fixed $k$. The qualitative $o(k^n)$ bound from the source paper may also follow from earlier work of Dinur, Friedgut, and Regev (as noted in the paper's revised version). Author names for 2307.01356 are from PDF metadata extraction and may need independent verification.
Context
This is posed in Section 4 as a concrete and more modest goal, falling short of identifying the exact extremal size: even a polynomial gain over the $o(k^n)$ bound of Theorem 1.1, expressed as $\log_k |A| \leq n - cn^\delta$, would be a significant advance.
Notes. PDF source — math notation may be garbled. No labeled environment; introduced with 'it would be very interesting to at least show' in Section 4.
Source paper
On symmetric intersecting families of vectors
Sean Eberhard, Jeff Kahn, Bhargav Narayanan, Sophie Spirkl · 2020-07-31
https://arxiv.org/abs/1909.11578
PDF source